Archive for December, 2005

Campaign Tracking and Optimisation

When you have a successful campaign running, you want it to make as much money as possible per day. How are you going to achieve that? You may be surprised to learn that it’s not by buying as many clicks as possible. Let’s look at some example figures.

Example 1: You make $17.83 per commission. Clicks cost you $0.10, and you ad appears in average position 3. You make one sale per 150 clicks, and you get an average of 15 clicks per day. You make an average of $2.83 per sale after advertising costs. You will make an average of $0.283 per day after advertising costs as it takes 10 days to make a sale on average.

Example 2: You make $17.83 per commission. Clicks cost you $0.09, and your ad appears in average position 5. You make one sale per 130 clicks, and you get an average of 12 clicks per day. You will make an average of $6.13 per sale after advertising costs. You will make an average of $0.566 per day after advertising costs as it takes 11.67 days to make a sale on average.

Example 3: You make $17.83 per commission. Clicks cost you $0.03, and you ad appears in average position 13. You make one sale per 120 clicks, and you get an average of one click per day. You will make an average of $14.23 per sale after advertising costs. You will make an average of $0.119 per day after advertising costs as it takes 120 days to make a sale on average.

(Why does the number of sales per click differ between the examples? Simply because someone who clicks through on an ad in a lower position is more likely to convert than someone who clicks through on a higher spot. They’ve looked at more ads and decided not to click through on those ads, so they have gone through a greater process of selection to get to your ad. Of course, the click-through rate will probably be lower.)

Example 2 shows practically double the income per day after just one change in advertising price point, compared to example 1! You really need to try each price point, and see what income you make over a period of time. It’s unfortunate, but that’s the way the statistics work. I suggest you wait until you have made at least five sales or 250 clicks on a campaign before making changes to improve the accuracy of the results.

You will probably find that there is a specific Max CPC that maximises the net commission per day. This is what you’re looking for. A graph showing net commission per day as a function of maximum cost per click will probably have one peak, with the value dropping to either side of the peak.

You must keep diligent records of your changes to make this work. Record the average, or mean, commission; the mean cost per click (use the campaign cost divided by the number of clicks, and not Google’s rounded figure); the maximum CPC; the mean number of clicks per day; and the mean number of clicks before an action occurs (sale or lead). Also record the start and end dates of the period, and the number of impressions over the period; you’ll need these for comparison purposes. You can get some of this information easily through Google’s reports, but not all of it. Not all of these numbers are needed for the optimisation calculation to be performed, but they are all useful pieces of information.

To help you, use a spreadsheet package. Use Excel if you have it; otherwise get OpenOffice Calc from the free office package at OpenOffice.org, which is worth far more than it costs! I use OpenOffice Calc. I suggest you set it up with these headings, and where I have put formulae in square brackets, you can enter these directly into OpenOffice Calc, and probably also Excel, onto the second row. The cells can then be copied throughout the column, and the cell references in the formulae will have the row numbers automatically updated:

  • A: Start Date
  • B: End Date
  • C: Number of Days [=B2-A2+1]
  • D: Gross Commission over Period
  • E: Number of Sales
  • F: Average Commission [=D2/E2]
  • G: Total Impressions
  • H: Average Impressions/Day [=G2/C2]
  • I: Total Clicks
  • J: Average Clicks/Day [=I2/C2]
  • K: Average Clicks/Sale [=I2/E2]
  • L: Maximum Cost per Click
  • M: Campaign cost over period
  • N: Average Cost/Click [=M2/I2]
  • O: Net Commission over Period [=D2-M2]
  • P: Return on Investment [=(D2/M2)-1]
  • Q: Net Commission per Day [=O2/C2]

I suggest you highlight the cells that are calculated on-the-fly by the spreadsheet, to remind you that you do not enter the numbers in these cells.

Note that although return on investment is included as column P, this is not the figure you would usually wish to maximise. You want to maximise the net commission per day, in column Q. Usually, maximising return on investment will give you a low net commission per day, simply because you would achieve the highest return on investment by having the lowest possible cost per click, which means you see few clicks!

The spreadsheet with the above headings fits very nicely on my 1280 x 1024 standard-size fonts screen. It is available from the download tools page. To get access for free, sign up to my affiliate marketing mailing list by using the sign-up form at the top of the page.

I hope you found this article helpful. Check back often for more hints and tips!

David Thomas, The Affiliate Marketer

Problems with a Rich Jerk technique

The Rich Jerk E-Book is yet another guide to making money on the Internet. Whereas the guide does contain some good ideas, there are other ideas that are rather dubious.

One of the ideas given in the book is that you could promote ClickBank products by offering a reduced price for each product, giving the customer some “cash back.” How this is meant to work is as follows:

  1. Customer buys product through your affiliate link.
  2. Customer waits 60 days. After this time, they will not be able to get a refund from ClickBank.
  3. Customer presents you with the ClickBank order number.

You then check the details, and if you find the order amongst your records, you provide your purchaser with whatever payment you promised them. Simple as that!

Somebody has tried this approach to making money, and it has upset some vendors. I believe that the reason for this is simply that their prices are being undermined, and therefore they are getting competition from a corner they didn’t expect. This is especially the case for “natural” visitors, i.e. those who have come across the site and decide to buy the product without buying through an affiliate link. If they grant 50% commission and the person buying the product recognises that the product is sold by ClickBank and then goes through the rebate site to buy it, that vendor has lost 50%.

It’s even worse for other affiliates. The customer clicks through a perfectly acceptable AdWords ad, finds out the product is a ClickBank product, then goes to the rebate site. The original affiliate has lost out on all of the income that they would otherwise have got.

The account of the person offering the ClickBank rebate has been disabled. They claim they are going to fight it, but I don’t see exactly how they are going to do this. In my opinion, it has now been proved that this technique is unsuitable for generating affiliate income.

David Thomas, The Affiliate Marketer

Tracking with Commission Junction

I like to know certain information about the people who buy the products that I promote. The following are handy to know:

1. What keyword did they use to visit my site?
2. Did they come from the search network or the content network?
3. When did they visit my site? (Useful to know, so that you know how long after they clicked on your link before they actually made the purchase.)
4. What was their IP address? (You may then be able to find out exactly what they did on your site, by rummaging through your logs.)

Using Commission Junction’s Shopper ID tracking, here’s how it’s done!

  1. Design your page using your normal page design techniques, ensuring that the SID in each link is set to TRACKMEHERE.
  2. When you have saved your page with a .html extension, change the extension to .php.
  3. Add the following at the top of the file, before anything else:
    <?php
      $source = $_SERVER['REMOTE_ADDR'] . ' ';
      $source .= gmdate('mdHis') . ' ';
      if (isset($_GET['keyword'])) {
        $source .= $_GET['keyword'];
      }
      $source = trim($source);
      $source = strtr($source, ' ', '+');
    ?>
  4. Wherever TRACKMEHERE appears in your document, replace it with the following:
    <?php echo $source; ?>
  5. Add the following query parameter to your destination URLs in AdWords:
    ?keyword={ifcontent:CN+}{KeyWord}
    A sample URL might be:
    http://myurl.com/index.php?
    keyword={ifcontent:CN+}{KeyWord}

That’s it. You’re done.

When somebody causes an action that appears in your CJ logs, such as makes a purchase, the SID will be set to the following:

  1. The IP address of the user.
  2. Exactly when the page was served. This consists of five pairs of digits, with the first pair of numbers being the month, the second pair the date, the third pair the hour (24-hour clock), the fourth pair the minute, and the last pair the second. I chose not to include the year, as it’s very unlikely that cookies on CJ are ever set to run for longer than 365 days. Note: As your server may be located in a different time zone than your own, the time shown is given in UTC, or GMT. If you prefer to use local time, remove the “gm” in front of “gmdate” in the PHP code at the start of the web page.
  3. The letters ‘CN’ if the click came from the content network.
  4. The search keyword used when the ad appeared. (This is probably only meaningful for the search network. I’m not sure what it displays when somebody clicks through from the content network.)

You can test it by going to your URL and entering a query parameter straight away, and looking at the CJ affiliate links generated. They should all contain something like the following:

sid=123.234.123.234+1217123840+Test+Keyword

(The above would mean customer IP address of 123.234.123.234; date and time of 17th Dec, 12:38:40; not the content network (no CN after the date and time); and keyword of Test Keyword caused the ad impression.)

With this information, you can start building up a picture of which keywords convert to sales; how long it takes for the average customer to buy; what customers do on your site; and whether it’s worth paying for content network clicks.

David Thomas, The Affiliate Marketer

Search engine optimization

This article is of use to you if you have a web site that you’d like to promote for any reason; whether it contains affiliate links, AdSense ads, or even your own product that you sell!

I wanted to give a brief mention to Brad Callen’s website. In it, he sells his SEOElite product, a program designed to help boost the rankings of your website in the search engines. If you’ve been in this game for a while, and especially have been promoting ClickBank products, you’ll recognise the style of the sales page. (Why is every product to do with making money on the Internet sold in an overhyped manner? It tends to put me off the product!) Don’t let it put you off, though; I have heard good things from other people about the program. I don’t have it yet, but that’s simply because I haven’t had time to get round to it.

What I really want to impress upon you is the quality of the email course that you will get if you subscribe to it from the SEOElite page. This is free, and you get lots of excellent strategies to assist you in promoting your web page for search engine results and other sorts of traffic. You don’t have to buy the program to use these tips! There are plenty of email lists targeted at affiliate marketers where the list content promotes specific products, and that’s it. This is not one of them; it really is quality, and is well worth subscribing to. If you subscribe to it, you get one email per day with a link to one of Brad’s pages that gives advice on search engine optimization. It doesn’t end there, however; continue to subscribe and you will get information on further techniques on an ad-hoc basis.

David Thomas, The Affiliate Marketer

Press Equalizer Special Offer

Press Equalizer is a tool that will enable you to quickly elevate the ranking of your web site within the major search engines and get plenty of free traffic! It works by submitting press releases that you make to various distribution sites on your behalf, and helps you to organise this process. These press releases get copied by various sites on the net, and this means that plenty of one-way links to your web site are created for you all around the web, which are just the kind of links you need to get your site’s ranking elevated. You will then be listed in a very short time, days or sometimes even hours, and you won’t have to mess around with link exchanges and other forms of search engine optimisation!

Until the 10th December 2005, you can pick this tool up along with a special bonus that usually sells for US$97 – Submit Equalizer – at the special price of US$77 (plus VAT if you are in the European Union) by following this link:

Press Equalizer

After the 10th, the price will go up to US$97.

The authors are offering a no-quibble guarantee for 60 days, so if during that time you decide that the product is not for you, you can return it for your money back. Note that I haven’t purchased or tested the product. If you buy it and try it out, please leave a comment with your opinion so that other readers can decide whether it is in their interests to buy it.

David Thomas, The Affiliate Marketer